The Journal

Buying a Trained Protection Dog? Ask These Questions Before You Pay

JournalProtection Dogs
Protection dog training scenario at a door

"Trained" means nothing until you ask three more questions: trained for what, trained for where, and trained for who. Many protection dogs for sale online look perfect on video, with a hard bite, clean obedience, nice music and slow motion, but many of them would never bite a real person on a dark street with your family behind you. A video shows what a dog can do on a good day, in a place he knows.

Key takeaways

  • Ask to see the release, not only the bite. A dog that engages but will not let go on a word is half-trained, and a half-trained protection dog is not half safe.
  • Ask to see the dog away from his training field: on a street, in a busy place, inside a house.
  • Muzzle work is a good truth test: a decoy with no bite equipment shows if the dog goes for the man or only for the sleeve.
  • A protection dog has to be born first. Training cannot create nerves or courage that are not there.
  • The dog has to work for you, so ask how the seller will teach you to handle him.

Watch the Video: Don't Buy a Protection Dog Until You Watch This

What does "trained protection dog" really mean?

Every seller uses the word: fully trained, elite trained, professionally trained. It means nothing until you ask:

  1. Trained for what? The job.
  2. Trained for where? The place.
  3. Trained for who? The handler.

Think about a pilot with a thousand hours in a flight simulator. He knows every button and every procedure. Would you get on his plane for his first real flight, in a real storm? The simulator is predictable. The weather is not. A lot of the protection dogs you see in videos are simulator dogs: very good in the world they already know.

Trained for what? Can the dog let go?

Most people think the job of a protection dog is biting. The bite matters, but it is the easy part to film. They all love to bite. What matters for your family is everything around the bite.

  • Can he let go on a word? Not when the handler pulls him off. When the handler says it.
  • Can he go from full aggression to a down right away? Not in ten seconds. In my training, that switch from switched on back to listening has to become almost a reflex. Three seconds is already a long time: in three seconds a dog can bite someone. At your front door, with your kids inside, three seconds is a lifetime.

So ask the seller: do not only show me the bite, show me the release. Show me the dog coming back to the handler. Show me the dog going from aggression to a down on voice, in one take, with no cut. And watch the edit. If every clip ends right after the bite, ask yourself why. Watch what the dog does after he lets go. Does he guard, come back to heel, go into a down? For me, the release is one of the most important parts of the whole training. Letting go does not mean the dog lost. It means he follows what the handler told him.

What about the e-collar? At TYR Protection Dogs we use the e-collar as a training method, but our dogs obey without it and go home without needing it. It is just a tool. Ask to see the control with no collar on the dog. If the control only exists while the collar is on, you need to know that before you pay.

Trained for where? Away from the field

This is where simulator dogs get found out. In sport and demonstration work, the dog knows the field, the helper, the pattern, the timing and the equipment. Everything is repeated, and for the dog it is a game. That does not make them bad dogs. A strong bite in prey drive is not a problem: many police and military dogs bite in prey drive, and that is fine for specific exercises. But a dog chasing someone down the street is not necessarily in full aggression.

The problem is what happens when the picture changes. A real person does not hold out a clean sleeve. He moves differently, smells different, screams, grabs, panics and runs. If a dog has never learned to work through that pressure, when it is real he can freeze, avoid or shut down. The question is always the same: does this dog understand the situation, or only the equipment? You can teach almost any dog to bite a sleeve. Biting equipment is not the same as facing danger.

Protection dog training scenario at a door

What is the muzzle test?

One way we look at this at TYR Protection Dogs is with a muzzle: an open basket muzzle and a decoy with no bite equipment. A friend of mine, a good decoy in the United States, once told me "the muzzle is the truth," and I agree with him 100%. The dog has to go for the man, not the sleeve, because there is no sleeve. If a dog is only focused on the equipment, the muzzle shows it very fast. So ask the seller: has this dog worked without any equipment? Can I see it?

What should the dog do in normal life?

A protection dog spends almost all of his life not protecting anybody. He lives in your house, rides in your car and meets your visitors and the delivery guy. What he does at the training center does not mean he does it in real life. Ask to see him away from where he was trained: on a street, in a busy place, inside a house. You want a dog who ignores normal people and is relaxed when nothing is happening, but who switches on when it is real.

Be careful with the opposite. A dog who reacts to everybody is not a protection dog, he is a liability. And the dog who barks the loudest behind the fence is very often in defense: he is not saying "come here," he wants the person to go away. If a seller only shows you a dog barking and completely crazy, that is not a protection dog. I explain the difference in would your dog actually protect you.

Protection dog working outdoors away from the training field

Where does the dog come from?

A protection dog has to be born first. Training develops what is already inside the dog's heart. It cannot create nerves or courage that are not there. That is genetic. So ask how the dog was raised, ask about the parents, and ask who selected the dog and when.

  • Was he bought as a finished sport dog? Some dogs sold as elite protection dogs were bought as finished sport dogs at 12 to 15 months old. In my experience, that is much more common than you imagine. Many dogs sold as fully trained protection dogs are sport dogs with a few things changed: a new video, a new price. That only works when the genetics were already there, which is rare.
  • How many breeds does the seller offer? If a seller offers protection dogs in a lot of different breeds, be careful. Most dogs, even most big dogs, will never be real protection dogs. Most of the protection dogs I prepare are working-line German Shepherds, because their genetics give me a much better chance of a stable dog that can live in a family home and still respond when it is real.
  • What happens to the dogs that do not make it? Not every dog makes it. With us, a dog without real protection quality is sold honestly as a pet, or I give him away. I did that recently with a dog who did not show me what I need from a protection dog.
  • How long did the training take? Real protection training is months, not weeks. It often starts when the dog is a puppy and goes until he is mature in body and in head. Honestly, it never stops.

My overall view on genetic selection, real-world training and family balance is on my page about how I select protection dogs. If you want to know how this training works from the inside, read how real protection dogs are trained, and for how I judge the dog in front of you, how to choose a protection dog and TYR's article on real-life training vs sport.

Trained for who? The part buyers forget

Say you find the right dog: good genetics, raised right, real control, tested in real life. That dog was trained by one person, the trainer. A protection dog that only listens to the person who trained him is not finished. He has to work for you. Remember the pilot: now it is you in that seat, and you have never flown.

That is why, at my company, we deliver the dog personally at the client's home. Normally it takes two or three days and we stay as long as it takes until the dog is really handed over. We train the people who will handle him, the family, and sometimes the family's security team, inside the house. Then there are follow-ups every six months or once a year, depending on the client.

I am not telling you this to sell you a dog, though you are welcome to buy one from me. I tell you because it is a question to ask every seller: how are you going to teach me to handle this dog? Most people who buy these dogs do not have experience. If the answer is a crate at the airport and a list of commands, the training stays with the seller, and you get a powerful dog who does not know you yet.

Who should own a protection dog?

A protection dog is not for image, and it does not replace your own awareness and discipline. The right owner stays calm under pressure and is consistent every day, because regular training is what keeps the control alive. I go deeper in who should and should not own a protection dog.

FAQ

How do I know if a protection dog is really trained?

Ask to see the release on voice with no cut, the dog going from aggression to a down, the dog working without equipment (muzzle work), and the dog away from his training field, with no collar on.

What questions should I ask a protection dog seller?

Trained for what, where and who. Plus: where does the dog come from, who selected him and when, how many breeds do they sell, what happens to the dogs that do not make it, how long did the training take, and how will you teach me to handle him?

How long does it take to train a protection dog?

Real protection training takes months, not weeks. It often starts in puppyhood and continues until the dog is mature in body and mind, and the control needs regular training for life.

How much does a trained protection dog cost?

It depends on the genetics, the months of training and who hands the dog over to you, so do not buy on price alone. At TYR Protection Dogs, trained dogs start from $20,000, and shipping is arranged separately. A price that looks too good is a reason to ask the questions in this article before you pay.

Is a sport dog the same as a protection dog?

No. A strong sport bite can be prey drive on a field the dog knows. A protection dog has to understand the real situation, release on voice, and stay stable in a family home.

Before you pay

See the release, not only the bite. See the dog away from his field. Ask how he was raised and how the seller will teach you. Then do the work: whatever dog you end up with, the control is the part you have to own. My free book, Drive & Control, shows how I build it: ruinavarro.com/youtube. If you want a step-by-step plan with weekly video lessons, where I review the videos of your dog, see the Drive Control Protocol (DCP). And if you are looking for a fully trained German Shepherd protection dog, you can see TYR Protection Dogs.

Back to the journal

Let’s start a conversation

The right dog.
The right foundation.

Family protection, training or breeding. Tell me what you have in mind.